Thursday, November 29, 2012

Does Clustered Index physically orders the data within a page?





I got new topic (for me) from our user group meeting (17/10/2012). There was a question from Dinesh Priyankara (MVP), what he asked from audience “Does Clustered Index physically order the data within a page? “ Majority of the audience said  'yes' including myself. Then he said it is another myth in SQL server world.  

Then I came and searched on Internet and did small work to break that myth. Here the truth..

“Clustered Index doesn't physically order the data within a page “

This is the script :


SET NOCOUNT ON
USE tempdb
GO
-- Create dbo.Without_Clustered_Index table (Heap Table)
CREATE TABLE dbo.Without_Clustered_Index
       (
              ID int ,
              Test varchar(10)
       )

-- Create  dbo.With_Clustered_Index table
CREATE TABLE dbo.With_Clustered_Index
       (
              ID int ,
              Test varchar(10)
       )
      
-- Create Unique Clustered index on dbo.With_Clustered_Index
CREATE UNIQUE CLUSTERED INDEX UCI_With_Clustered_Index_ID_PK ON dbo.With_Clustered_Index
       (
              ID
       )




-- Insert data into dbo.Without_Clustered_Index table

INSERT INTO dbo.Without_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 10 ,'Ten')
INSERT INTO dbo.Without_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 8 ,'Eight')
INSERT INTO dbo.Without_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 7 ,'Seven')


-- Insert data into dbo.With_Clustered_Index table

INSERT INTO dbo.With_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 10 ,'Ten')
INSERT INTO dbo.With_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 8 ,'Eight')
INSERT INTO dbo.With_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 7 ,'Seven')



SELECT ID,Test
FROM dbo.Without_Clustered_Index

SELECT ID,Test
FROM dbo.With_Clustered_Index



-- Set to instruct the engine to send output to the console;
DBCC TraceOn (3604)
GO

-- List all of a table's data and index pages
DBCC IND ('TempDB','dbo.Without_Clustered_Index',1)
GO

DBCC IND ('TempDB','dbo.With_Clustered_Index',1)
GO


-- 288 and 290 are the data page ID for dbo.Without_Clustered_Index and dbo.With_Clustered_Index tables respectively
-- Look at the contents of database pages
DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,288,2) --with tableresults
GO

DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,290,2) --with tableresults
GO



-- Insert data into dbo.Without_Clustered_Index table

INSERT INTO dbo.Without_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 4 ,'Four')
INSERT INTO dbo.Without_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 3 ,'Three')

-- Insert data into dbo.With_Clustered_Index table

INSERT INTO dbo.With_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 4 ,'Four')
INSERT INTO dbo.With_Clustered_Index(ID,Test) VALUES ( 3 ,'Three')




-- Look at the contents of database pages
DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,288,2) --with tableresults
GO
 

DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,290,2) --with tableresults
GO

   
  


-- Update Existing Record from each record

UPDATE dbo.Without_Clustered_Index SET ID = 1 WHERE ID = 4
UPDATE dbo.With_Clustered_Index SET ID = 1 WHERE ID = 4

-- Look at the contents of database pages
DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,288,2) --with tableresults
GO

 




DBCC PAGE ('TempDB',1,290,2) --with tableresults
GO

 

  
Conclusion :
In Row offset,  0th  entry value changed into new record distance value (173 to 193) and 1st  entry value changed into 173 by removing 154 (154 is the distance value of the ID = 4 value record). We updated ID = 4 into ID= 1
Instead of modifying existing record it adds new record with same value by updating required value.

No comments:

Post a Comment